Tuesday, February 27, 2024

Materials: From Graphene to Borophene Electronics

Dr S.S. Verma is a professor at Department of Physics, Sant Longowal Institute of Engineering and Technology, Sangrur, Punjab

- Advertisement -

The discovery of graphene in 2004 by two researchers, Prof. Andre Geim and Prof. Kostya Novoselov at the University of Manchester (UK), created quite an excitement. This pioneering work won the duo Nobel Prize in Physics in 2010.

However, there are some inherited limitations of graphene as a wonder material, forcing scientists to look for an alternative.

In this quest, they have discovered a new two-dimensional (2D) material called ‘borophene’ that is thought to exhibit electronic properties better than graphene. This article dwells on the journey from graphene to borophene.

- Advertisement -


Graphene is a one-atom thin sheet of carbon atoms arranged in a hexagonal format or a flat monolayer of carbon atoms that are tightly packed into a 2D honeycomb lattice. Owing to exceptional strength, flexibility and conductance, it is expected to shape almost all aspects of future technologies.

Researchers around the world have found that graphene has promise for applications in electronics ranging from displays to random-access memory.

Noted for the speed at which electrons pass through it, graphene has already proved to be a miracle electronic material with properties suitable for design of strong, fast, flexible and transparent electronic devices, printed graphene in paper electronics, and car batteries.

Flexible and transparent electronics

Flexible and transparent electronics (Image courtesy: Berkeley Lab, USA)

Its limitations

With applications touching humans in every quartet of life, graphene seems to have limitless capabilities, though with the traditional challenge of its production cost. In 2013, a graphene flake the size of one micrometre cost more than $1000. Obviously, this is why graphene is one of the most expensive materials on Earth.

However, upscaling of graphene production is one of the most researched subjects and we are not far away from attaining scalability of the graphene production process. Researchers have devised a method for producing graphene-treated silver nanowires, which could significantly reduce production costs for nanowire-based displays.

This could mean that graphene offers a real alternative to indium-tin oxide in flexible low-cost touchscreen displays.

Nevertheless, some of the major limitations of graphene include:
1. High bending stiffness for devices that also need to stretch, compress or even twist.
2. Band gap not suitable to simply get the characteristics of switch on and off.
3. High susceptibility to oxidative environments when used as a catalyst
4. Some toxic qualities. Scientists have discovered that graphene features jagged edges that can easily pierce cell membranes, allowing it to enter into cells and disrupt normal functions.

Borophene and its properties

Scientists are interested in two-dimensional materials mainly for their unique electronic properties. Borophene is an unusual material because it shows many metallic properties at nanoscale. Even though three-dimensional, or bulk, boron is nonmetallic and semiconducting.

Recently, researchers successfully synthesised borophene. The outcome was not only similar to graphene but also much lighter and stronger, contributing to the novel desirable properties.

Researchers showed that it has a record high flexibility, a higher stiffness-to-weight ratio and higher ideal strength than graphene and the polymers currently used.

The superconductivity of borophene is critical. Borophene grown on a silver substrate takes a wavy form, which makes it suitable for flexible electronics. As a 2D metal, it helps fill a void in the family of 2D nanoelectronic materials.

With the synthesis and characterisation of borophene researchers have moved a step ahead.

Properties such as low mass density, high strength and high levels of flexibility make borophene a promising candidate as a reinforced element for designing composites and for flexible nanodevices, such as flexible electrodes and contacts for nanoelectronics.


Wavy borophene (Image courtesy: Zhuhua Zhang/Rice University)

Development status

Most of the work with borophene so far has been aimed at synthesis as well as characterisation of the material’s properties. Advanced computer simulation methods showed formation of crinkles in the corrugated surface.

Borophene is a proposed allotrope of boron made up of single-atom sheets. The research reveals that one cluster consists of 36 boron atoms arranged in a two-dimensional sheet with a perfect hexagonal hole in the middle, which is of real significance.

It suggests that theoretical calculations about a boron planar structure might be right.

Although bulk allotropes of carbon and boron differ greatly, in nano regime small clusters of these elements show remarkable similarities. Boron analogues of two-dimensional carbon allotropes such as graphene have been predicted.

Researchers demonstrated theoretically that borophene is enriched with more interesting electronic characteristics than graphene but a strong foothold in production was missing.

Theoretical studies predict that 2D boron sheets will adopt an atomic configuration similar to that of boron atomic clusters. Recently, researchers successfully synthesised borophene using molecular beam epitaxy.

They reported the formation of two-dimensional boron by depositing the elemental boron onto a silver surface under ultra-high-vacuum conditions. The graphene-like structure was buckled, weakly bonded to the substrate, and metallic.

Borophene prefers to be flat because that’s where its energy is lowest. It, however, needs the underlying substrate to make it wavy. When grown on a featureless surface, its natural form is flat like graphene. When grown on silver, borophene adopts its accordion-like form while silver reconstructs itself to match.

Once borophene is formed, it can easily be removed as the bond between silver and borophene is weak. This may allow atom-thick slices of borophene to be transferred to any substrate once it has been formed with the corrugations.

This wavy conformation so far seems unique due to the exceptional structural flexibility and particular interactions of borophene with silver, and may be initially triggered by a slight compression in the layer when a bit too many boron atoms get onto the surface.

For the first time, research team has made composites and combined borophene with another material to create heterostructures as the fundamental building block for fabrication of electronic devices.


Borophene is both metallic and atomically thin, holding great promise for applications ranging from electronics to photovoltaics.

2D materials like graphene are touted as ideal for electronics but graphene being too flat and hard to stretch for flexible, wearable devices, wavy borophene might prove better than graphene. Borophene-based heterostructures will guide future and ongoing research into using it for functional nanoelectronic devices.

What the future holds

There is a need to develop reliable encapsulation and/or passivation schemes that allow borophene to be removed from an ultra-high-vacuum environment so that a practical device could actually be fabricated and tested.

When borophene is on silver (both of which are metallic), the silver substrate electrically shorts borophene, which creates serious problems for any device application. This calls for transfer of borophene from the silver growth substrate to an electrically insulating substrate.

Borophene could be the key to the future wearable and stretchable devices, owing to its flexibility while exhibiting electrical properties. Materials that are not only flexible but can also stretch would enable electronics to be mounted onto any surface with much lower chances of breaking up.

Superconductive materials are highly valuable in the wearable industry, where signals must flow without any issue. Therefore borophene may also find its way into the future of superconductors and, coupled with room-temperature superconductors, it may change the world forever. Hence more work is required before the full potential of borophene is realised in electronic applications.


Electronics News

Truly Innovative Tech

MOst Popular Videos

Electronics Components