Sunday, July 14, 2024

Difference Between Microprocessor and Microcontroller

- Advertisement -

Choosing the appropriate device as the foundation for your new design can be overwhelming. The need to make the right balance of price, performance, and power consumption has many implications.

However, if a microcontroller (MCU) or microprocessor (MPU) becomes the basis of a platform approach, the decision can have long-lasting consequences. The difference between microprocessors and microcontrollers becomes a critical debate at this point.

The table below explains the microprocessor and microcontroller difference.

- Advertisement -

Difference Between Microprocessor and Microcontroller

MicrocontrollerMicroprocessor
Microcontroller Block DiagramMicroprocessor Block Diagram
  • The microcontroller is the heart of an embedded system.
  • The microprocessor is the heart of a Computer system.
  • The microcontroller has an external processor along with internal memory and i/O components
  • It is just a processor. Memory and I/O components have to be connected externally
  • Since memory and I/0 are present internally, the circuit is small.
  • Since memory and I/O have to be connected externally, the circuit becomes large.
  • Can be used in compact systems and hence it is an efficient technique
  • Cannot be used in compact systems and hence inefficient
  • The cost of the entire system is low
  • Cost of the entire system increases
  • Since external components are low, total power consumption is less and can be used with devices running on stored power like batteries.
  • Due to external components, the entire power consumption is high. Hence it is not suitable to use with devices running on stored power like batteries.
  • Most microcontrollers have power-saving modes like idle mode and power-saving mode. This helps to reduce power consumption even further.
  • Most microprocessors do not have power-saving features.
  • Since components are internal, most of the operations are internal instruction, hence speed is fast.
  • Since memory and I/O components are all external, each instruction will need an external operation, hence it is relatively slower.
  • Microcontrollers have more registers, hence the programs are easier to write.
  • Microprocessors have less number of registers, hence more operations are memory based
  • Microcontrollers are based on Harvard architecture where program memory and Data memory are separate
  • Microprocessors are based on the von Neumann model/architecture where programs and data are stored in the same memory module
  • Used mainly in washing machines, MP3 players
  • Mainly used in personal computers
Microcontroller Internal Parts
Microcontroller Internal Parts

Microprocessor VS Microcontroller: Primary Differences

Typically an MCU uses on-chip embedded Flash memory in which to store and execute its program. Storing the program this way means the MCU has a shorter start-up period and executes code quickly. The only practical limitation to using embedded memory is that the total available memory space is finite.

Most Flash MCU devices available on the market have a maximum of 2 Mbytes of Program memory. This may prove to be a limiting factor, depending on the application.

MPUs do not have memory constraints in the same way. They use external memory to provide program and data storage. The program is typically stored in non-volatile memory, such as NAND or serial Flash.

At start-up, this is loaded into an external DRAM and execution commences. This means the MPU will not be up and running as quickly as an MCU but the amount of DRAM and NVM you can connect to the processor is in the range of hundreds of Mbytes and even Gbytes for NAND.

Another difference is power. By embedding its own power supply, an MCU needs just one single-voltage power rail. By comparison, an MPU requires several different voltage rails for the core, DDR, etc. The developer needs to cater to this with additional power ICs / converters on board.

Microcontroller Vs Microprocessor: Application Perspective

From the application perspective, some aspects of the design specification might drive device selection in particular ways. For example, is the number of peripheral interface channels required more than can be catered for by an MCU?

Or, does the marketing specification stipulate a user interface capability that will not be possible with an MCU because it does not contain enough memory on-chip or has the required performance?

When embarking on the first design and know that it is highly likely there will be many product variations. In that case, it is very possible a platform-based design approach will be preferred.

This would stipulate more “headroom” in terms of processing power and interface capabilities in order to accommodate future feature upgrades.

Difference Between Microprocessor and Microcontroller: Connectivity Standpoint

From the connectivity standpoint, most MCU and MPU devices are available, with all the common popular peripheral interfaces. High-speed communication peripherals such as HS USB 2.0, multiple 10/100 Ethernet ports, or Gigabit Ethernet ports are generally only found on MPU.

They are better capable to handle and process large amounts of data. Whether there are enough suitable channels and bandwidth to handle the data traffic is a key question.

Depending on the communication protocols used, the impact on code space using third-party stacks should be checked. Applications demanding high-speed connectivity, especially in combination with using OS-based stacks will require an MPU-based design.

Another key aspect driving the difference between microprocessor and microcontroller selection is the need for a real-time/deterministic behavior of the application.

Because of the processor core used in an MCU, as well as the embedded flash and considering the software used that is either an RTOS or bare metal C, the MCU will definitely take the lead on this aspect and will address perfectly the most time-critical and deterministic applications.

Difference Between Microcontroller and Microprocessor: Power Consumption

A final point to consider is power consumption. While MPUs have low power modes there are not as many or as low as the ones you would find on a typical MCU. With the external hardware supporting an MPU as an added factor, putting an MPU into a low-power mode might also be slightly more complex.

Also, the actual consumption of an MCU is magnitudes lower than an MPU. In low power mode for example, with SRAM and register retention, you can consider a factor of 10 to 100. This is directly related to the amount of RAM and power required by an operating system to resume operation instantaneously.

The decisions involved in selecting either an MCU or MPU-based approach are many and involve performance, capability, and the BOM budget.

Three key differences between Microcontrollers and Microprocessors

  1. Integration: Microcontrollers are highly integrated devices that combine a microprocessor core with memory (both program memory and data memory) and various peripherals, such as input/output ports, timers, analog-to-digital converters, and communication interfaces, all on a single chip. Microprocessors, on the other hand, are standalone processing units that lack built-in memory and peripherals. They require external components for memory and peripheral interfacing.
  2. Purpose: Microcontrollers are designed for specific embedded applications, where they serve as the main processing unit controlling the system’s functions and interacting with the surrounding environment. They are optimized for low-power operation and real-time tasks. Microprocessors, on the other hand, are more general-purpose processors used in a wide range of computing applications, including personal computers, servers, mobile devices, and more.
  3. Complexity: Microcontrollers are typically simpler and less powerful than microprocessors. They have lower clock speeds, limited memory capacities, and fewer computational resources. This simplicity makes microcontrollers more cost-effective and suitable for resource-constrained embedded systems. Microprocessors, on the other hand, are more complex and powerful, with higher clock speeds, larger memory capacities, and greater computational capabilities. They are capable of running complex operating systems and handling demanding computational tasks.

It’s worth noting that these differences are not absolute, and there can be variations and overlaps in the capabilities of different microcontrollers and microprocessors based on their specific architectures and implementations.

Selecting One?

Broadly speaking, MCUs tend to be used in cost-optimized solutions which require tight control of BOM and power saving. Functionally rich and high-performance applications employ a scale, larger number of MPUs.

Ultra-low power applications such as remote controls, consumer electronics, and smart meters where the design emphasizes the longevity of battery life and no or little UI interaction find larger use of MCUs.

They are also used where highly deterministic behavior is needed. MPUs are ideal for OS-based industrial and consumer applications. These might be computed intensively and require multiple high-speed connectivities or a rich UI.

Selecting a vendor offering highly compatible MCU and MPU products where you can easily migrate up and down and maximize software reuse provides the best return on investment over time.

Computer Motherboard History
The History of computer motherboards

One of the most popular microcontrollers is the 8051 microcontroller.

People Also Ask!

Q: What is Microcontroller?

A microcontroller is a small integrated circuit that combines a microprocessor core, memory, and peripheral devices such as input/output ports, timers, and analog-to-digital converters. It is designed to perform specific tasks and control functions in embedded systems.

Microcontrollers are commonly used in various electronic devices, including home appliances, automotive systems, industrial machinery, and consumer electronics. They provide a cost-effective and efficient solution for applications that require control, monitoring, and interaction with the physical world.

Q: What is Microprocessor?

A microprocessor is a central processing unit (CPU) that is designed to execute instructions and perform arithmetic and logical operations in a computer system. It is an integrated circuit that serves as the “brain” of a computer or other electronic devices.

Microprocessors are responsible for carrying out the instructions of a computer program by fetching, decoding, and executing them. They are commonly found in personal computers, laptops, smartphones, and various electronic devices.
Unlike microcontrollers, microprocessors are typically used in systems that require general-purpose computing capabilities and are not dedicated to specific control functions

Q: Which is better, Microprocessor or a Microcontroller?

Ultimately, the choice between a microprocessor and a microcontroller depends on the specific application requirements, including processing power, system complexity, power consumption, cost, flexibility, and development considerations. It is essential to carefully evaluate these factors to determine which option best suits the project’s needs.

Q: Is Raspberry Pi a Microcontroller or Microprocessor?

The Raspberry Pi is a microprocessor-based single-board computer.

Q: Is Arduino a Microcontroller or Microprocessor?

Arduino is a microcontroller-based development board.

Q: Does every Microcontroller have a Microprocessor?

Yes, every microcontroller includes a microprocessor as its core component. The microprocessor is responsible for executing instructions and performing calculations within the microcontroller. However, it’s important to note that while all microcontrollers have a microprocessor, not all microprocessors are part of a microcontroller. Microprocessors can also be standalone components used in various applications.

Q: What are the Different Applications for Microprocessors and Microcontrollers?

Microprocessor use cases:
1. Personal computers
2. Servers
3. Mobile devices
4. Gaming consoles
5. High-performance computing

Microcontroller use cases:
1. Embedded systems
2. Automotive systems
3. Consumer electronics
4. Medical devices
5. Internet of Things (IoT) devices

12 COMMENTS

SHARE YOUR THOUGHTS & COMMENTS

Unique DIY Projects

Electronics News

Truly Innovative Tech

MOst Popular Videos

Electronics Components

Calculators

×